Out of Nowhere

Abstract

Abstract The two fundamental pillars of physics for over 100 years have been quantum theory and general relativity, but their unification at short distances remains elusive, both technically and conceptually. This work is a philosophical investigation of the second kind of problem, and in particular of the striking fact that in many approaches to ‘quantum gravity’ classical spacetime structures are not merely quantized, but arguably absent—so that spacetime is not merely a classical limit, but ‘emergent’. This issue is not only central to the problem of quantum gravity, but of deep significance for our philosophical understanding of physical reality, promising a conceptual revolution at least as profound as Einstein’s. We give an introduction to the question of spacetime emergence in general, for philosophers of metaphysics and science, and argue that spacetime functionalism explains how something non-spatiotemporal could ever appear as space and time. More technical chapters investigate the issue in detail for causal set theory, loop quantum gravity, and string theory, and the book also serves as a philosophical introduction to those theories for philosophers of physics. Our results help physicists clarify what new conceptual framework—not resting on space and time—may be necessary to achieve a theory of quantum gravity; and show philosophers how the world may not be spatiotemporal at root, and what kind of a world we might then live in.

Topics & Concepts