Molecular taxonomy of nociceptors and pruriceptors
Jussi Kupari, Patrik Ernfors
Abstract
1. Introduction The ability to feel the warmth of the sun or the coolness of a breeze on a summer's day; a pleasant caress of skin; to explore the texture, size, and shape of an object; and to feel pain as a mechanism to protect us from what is dangerous around us has fascinated mankind for centuries. Perhaps this fascination is rooted in the fact that the somatic senses of temperature, pain, touch, itch, and proprioception endow us with the ability to continuously stay in contact with the world within and around us. Attempting to explain how we react to heat, the 17th century philosopher René Descartes depicted a thread connecting the skin with the brain and particles of fire pulling on the thread.20 In the 1880s, distinct sensory spots on the skin were recognized and shown to respond to specific stimuli, such as touch, heat, or cold. This finding was taken as evidence for different sensations relying on the existence of distinct nerves tuned to specific types of stimuli.83,94 In the beginning of the 20th century, the discovery of different nerve fiber types with distinct conduction velocities, activation thresholds, and refractory periods made it possible to link specific fiber types to unique qualities of sensation, such as proprioception and different kinds of touch. Unlike innocuous touch and pressure, which are communicated through nerve fibers responding only to mechanical stimuli, noxious stimuli were found to activate a class of polymodal nociceptive nerve fibers responding to several kinds of unpleasant stimuli, including high-threshold mechanical force and intense heat.7,12 This work led to the general idea that the capacity to discriminate perceptual qualities arises from unique functions of a variety of sensory neurons involved in somatic sensation. This is possible because different neuron types are tuned to respond and transduce certain, but not all, kinds of stimuli, such as warm and cool temperatures, noxious heat, noxious cold, light punctate sensation, painful pressure, sharp objects, hair pull, chemical irritants, inflammatory substances, chemical and mechanical itch, and various kinds of touch and vibration.29,38 Apart from providing sensory awareness about our body and its surroundings, the somatosensory system is also essential for other functions we perform effortlessly and without much thought. For example, a continuous flow of information in a sensory–motor feedback loop involving several dozen muscles is necessary to coordinate movements when taking a sip from a glass of water or for the seemingly simple task of walking. Somatosensory neurons are also organized in discreet pathways with autonomic sympathetic and parasympathetic motor neurons driving reflexes involved in physiological homeostasis, such as thermoregulation through reflex control of sweat glands and selective vasoconstrictor systems in muscle and skin active when standing up and during hypothermia, respectively.16,49,74 Furthermore, pleasant and painful sensations involve not only discriminative perception and coordination of efferent reflex functions but also emotional and motivational components important for behavior. For example, social touch such as hugging and caressing induce sensations of pleasantness to facilitate emotional bonding, affiliative behavior, and well-being,82,88 while noxious stimuli not only convey sensory discriminative and protective reflexes but also include an affective-motivational dimension of unpleasantness contributing to long-term behavior avoiding harm.112,125 The existence of molecularly unique neuron types coding for each quality and dimension of somatosensation is unlikely. Instead, summation of activity and inactivity from different types of nerve fibers is likely to contribute to the sensory qualities and dimensions involved. Several recent studies support this conjecture, eg. the discovery of warmth sensation relying on the simultaneous activation of warmth-sensing and inhibition of cold-sensing nerves97; the requirement of different sensory neurons for protective reflexes and affective coping behavior elicited by the same stimuli45; the suppression of noxious cold (−10 to 10°C) by Calca+ neurons18,81; the modulation of touch-evoked itch by Merkel cells and Slc17a8-lineage (low-threshold mechanoreceptor [LTMR]) sensory neurons32,33,108; and alleviation of Npy2r+ neuron-dependent acute pain behavior by the simultaneous activity of the A-LTMR touch neurons.3 With a thorough molecular categorization of sensory neuron types, experiments can be designed with even greater precision, opening possibilities for gaining new, deeper insights into the cellular basis for nociception and pruriception. 2. Categorizing sensory neurons Sensory neurons have historically been classified based on physiological properties, morphology, target innervation, spinal termination, developmental hierarchy, and functional and neurochemical properties (reviewed by Emery and Ernfors, 202029). This work has been instrumental for deciphering how the peripheral sensory nervous system is organized. However, these strategies have measured a dozen or so quantitative features, such as response to cold, heat, and mechanical stimuli; conduction velocity; neuron size; or a handful of marker genes, which might not be sufficient for reliable identification of functional units. By contrast, single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) can measure thousands of features, is quantitative, and allows for an unbiased classification of cell types. Nevertheless, the accuracy of cell-type assignment is affected by quality sequencing and and the fact that only a of the RNA within a cell is for In different cell types different of in in sequencing cell-type This is for sensory neurons neurons of the nervous are of identification is also affected by the for The of in is to the neuron types which unique functional units. However, molecular cell-type are by the is the molecular and and is a cell Sensory neurons are with a of cells which is during RNA sequencing can be to of a information can be in the is when the is not to a of unique cell and the of RNA is a and the of and identification of cell types might be in through the of much of insights into cell-type can be to the of a of the by the of we have by and in this on by this are several studies on the of somatosensory and has been a general of to the to cell the different studies unbiased For this we have to information studies and and strategies to our as as the of by we the cells in these our of sensory neurons is by the molecular as in these of somatosensation the body somatosensory neurons are in the the and of the and and the with a in the In general somatosensory neurons be the Sensory neurons in the convey sensory information from the and the and and the from the and of the the and while neurons convey and sensation from the of the Unlike somatosensory neurons which and sensory neurons are involved in reflex functions body to and information from neurons are organized in including the and which are neuron types in the general somatosensory and by that the basis for somatosensation is the body while sensory neurons of the are by different kinds of However, of has led to the identification of neuron types not found in other studies of the the existence of somatosensory neuron types to The from this have not been with other unbiased and the and to neurons in other studies to be of sensory neuron types and functions on the molecular types of sensory neurons are of the neuron types, of sensory to neurons of the peripheral innervation, and is in 1. This also the the different neuron types as as and to cell-type during the molecular in and functional of sensory neuron types. types and are based on in The classification is based on and and the which Emery and is the of the The or a of neuron types with information fiber and of sensation by functional or based on high-threshold from to neuron sensory of of marker genes, and of the based on that the which is in the as of and The and neuron types which through and through and is for of neurons by and which into nociceptive and single-cell RNA of the include the innocuous by of and with functional in the and this is not on it is to that functional to into distinct molecular of and conduction The molecular properties these be and because of as unique types. By contrast, the molecular classification of not peripheral For example, only of neuron has been by which as in hair and in the and Furthermore, the fibers of of in Merkel cells or also as in hair have that and we to these studies as only and for the same and neuron types in with The the of neuron types, the within the can be are types of and with or can be into types with based on the the because of the for somatic sensations such as and a of itch are with the and The of and include the neuron types the and The types of cold-sensing types of polymodal neuron types or inflammatory and a high-threshold mechanoreceptor neuron types involved in light punctate reflex and itch and neuron types involved in itch and and and neuron involved in itch, itch, and perception of warmth and of these types have been shown to distinct functional unique functions for of the to be For example, are unique functions as to the other have only been for of these and and molecular of while recent studies on neurons found greater molecular to for and nerve Furthermore, a unique neuron has been but is to be in is likely to be the and to as a distinct cell to its and discovery of molecular neuron types be by the quality and of strategies of somatosensation neurons from have been by and as as and have the existence of cell types that the of sensory neuron types is these Nevertheless, when the of genes, in the neuron types of the and are of which to of somatosensory of has been and is a of strategies for from and the molecular neurons as by and or neurons have not been based on of neurons neuron types, and cell based on and not be to and to to to cold-sensing to to to to to to and were not and were in the a of the basis for studies are to the and molecular In and the quality and molecular of sensory neurons for the assignment of to neuron types with insights into the molecular we the molecular of and sensory neuron types based on studies cell different and studies have been shown unbiased and functions of the different neuron types with a on nociceptive and The cell-type and in these studies are in 2. For in we a for the and with an to the different cell-type or when in each of the different and a the and of only when in cell types. a molecular of sensory neuron types is essential for insights into the basis of somatosensation and for what in of the is around cell types or and is a by studies cell-type by strategies for or by activation and of different neuron types or in Furthermore, for in we to other on this of the neuron types and and and and not neurons neuron is because in and also in neuron also much The neuron neurons for cool sensation that also contribute to painful cold. the skin and likely also and about to of This neuron unique including and but the and and and only of while This is to the and for and identification of cell on marker with fibers and or not the by different types to be different of neurons have been in the that is active only during cool active only noxious cold and a with a with the of cold-sensing studies have the as a for cool in the also a behavior noxious cold, that the but is not essential noxious cold sensation. By contrast, the of sensory neurons to a of cold and a greater of noxious cold with only the has been studies the of neurons in innocuous and noxious cold while that other neuron types also in the of noxious cold through a mechanism of the neuron types. This is also by of fibers are with the while high-threshold cold also respond to noxious and mechanical the neurons are the only not in has on cold behavior to while responding to cold stimuli is Calca+ and neurons of molecular types were found to contribute to noxious cold through a mechanism cold-sensing neurons during cold The identification of several as cold has not in neuron types contributing to the noxious cold in and cold to activate sensory neuron types of likely because of neuron types have been shown to also in that activity in these neuron types can and The and include neurons involved in protective itch, and also In these neurons various to physiological of cells or are the in for noxious in and these neuron types, is the different in the and the while the and types are to each The and and are in the This might for through for and contributing as activation of the neurons and by to behavior in but so in it has been that of the types in the class are high-threshold with a to transduce and noxious itch is through specific kinds of chemical itch in the class of neurons in the and and from or the of cells to the for the inflammatory The is in and include and of which activate or and itch or is and class neurons in are to respond to such itch sensation while neurons are for mechanical and types of with this itch in is by nerves different from polymodal neurons The neurons are of in and and the of the in the and skin of the are polymodal fibers about to of neurons and are involved in and to light punctate mechanical stimuli This neuron unique molecular features, and while and only 1. This is to the for and identification of unique or not the of neurons distinct to be on physiological neurons can be by and stimuli in these neurons are for the reflex by punctate stimuli from not or cold Furthermore, are for the mechanical pain by with the behavior when neurons specific activation of fibers to behavior in the while it to so nerve and studies support the idea that while neurons are not in the perform this during inflammatory the of neurons to mechanical during pain, in to other neuron types, to be In the neurons are also involved in pruriception. neurons not respond to a and the which and Furthermore, the neuron is the only the in the in the neurons to as neurons in reflex to punctate stimuli and as to In based on neurons are to have functions for itch, for and different and with as be neurons neurons are of in the and the of the while around hair are polymodal high-threshold fibers responding to noxious mechanical and stimuli, but not and to of sensory In in the neurons have been to be a neuron to recent functions while and only This is to the for and identification of unique or not the of neurons distinct to be the cells are the cellular of the neurons in the has on pain behavior by and cold noxious stimuli, it induce in light punctate sensation by Furthermore, was in these in response to or mechanical stimuli in the By contrast, neurons are for itch through the activation of that are in these in the neurons are itch is and and several other itch on in the of also itch on and neuron types to be distinct functional in the to functions in to the itch is through the activation of this is not in and is while itch is by in the it is to in through and neurons through the of and neuron types in is also for is in the skin of inflammatory such as and itch through the activation of and or and in the are to through the of neurons based on in the are in and in the cell-type to can also be through the by of in the skin of with itch such as In itch is in This is in neurons in it is not only for itch but also mechanical This is not in is not in sensory neurons all, of to itch in to be through skin cell types much has been on as a to itch in the of and which can be by and including sensory neurons and in the and the and neurons to be in also in this of and neuron types is also for in of with and and can pain and itch in In and acute the on This is with the of through in neurons and in and nociceptive neurons also By contrast, in and neurons and in also the that itch from are and which activate the in is in and neurons of it that and neuron types are essential in for itch during Furthermore, a of and types of neurons by and might itch and by the same The is a through a of and likely an mechanism because sensory neurons not the in the or cell and is which has been to on sensory through the and based on the are as these are in and sensory to studies activation of class neurons not to recent neurons to be based on activation activation behavior while of the same cell This neurons as but that can also as with a of neuron types to pain was by with pain in sensory neuron types. for pain on different types, of which was a of neurons for itch is studies on to pain are neurons The neurons contribute to mechanical and chemical and are in to also in warmth sensation. are and and about to of neurons in the neurons are polymodal high-threshold fibers responding to noxious mechanical and but not cold the in functional for noxious mechanical and stimuli is likely and of have of a of in of which are with inflammatory and the unique of of these only in neurons a for these neurons in responding to specific activation of neurons has also been shown that in the which is in a of to a of and cell such as and itch and are in neurons and and neurons also which is as a for can several of which are in However, only and are in sensory neurons and are specific for of a to sensory neurons to but this is in from in which the neurons were itch behavior was in such it that neurons are for the of and of these functions are to be also in based on For example, is in neurons which also the and this are other in sensory Nevertheless, for other are also in and For example, are in and in to neurons contribute only to in is possible that the itch is through neurons because the is in and neurons in the By contrast, neurons can be to be for itch because is only in by is to on the activation of by and are in the neurons of and it itch in on neurons while in the and neurons and have been in itch by to or on is in the of neurons while is in However, sensory neurons of in and and in and with is in in cell a itch mechanism be the it that have functions to and in sensory mechanical itch in of sensory neurons which include and the Furthermore, through with the in to in these to a of for mechanical However, recent have mechanical itch to found mechanical itch and to mechanical itch in the is a in other nociceptive and is in neurons and to be for mechanical stimuli into itch sensation. The that a itch a sensation and the to to from the while a a selective to mechanical is only in neurons such mechanical be by a from itch to pain by these In to neurons might also contribute to the sensation of warmth through also pain to The warmth is in the neurons of and with a of a in the sensation of warmth in the of to However, warmth sensation in also as as neurons with activity in the neurons and inactivity in the it is possible that warmth sensation in several neuron types, of which is the Furthermore, of the pain to a coding of sensory information by simultaneous activity of and as to only This finding in might have a to experiments in the for without of or is how neurons can sensation and in on warmth sensation in involve different because is not in neurons are polymodal and that the skin and and about of In these neurons the and and the the and the neuron while and The in and is likely to in these The of and mechanical pain in with or inhibition of neurons but and has been to the types. Furthermore, this neuron is for pain sensation because the polymodal and neurons for and pain the basis for pain and contribute to during in However, for several other types unique have to to in the are studies to only the of to functional insights in the include and is in and neurons and in and neurons with a also in Nevertheless, as neurons are as the for and behavior to noxious heat, and during in inflammatory and pain as as for coping and behavior to noxious cold and mechanical activation of neurons and neuron by and how these neurons contribute to pain behavior. with of and neurons to in the of to were by Calca+ cells and neuron or the of of which reflex and coping behavior to noxious In coping behavior by is in neurons have been while to respond is recent that the of in the not to to noxious cold is a cold, skin and when such as coping behavior. that are for reflexes and coping behavior by noxious heat, as as for coping behavior elicited by cold and mechanical stimuli in the that are to acute and and behavior be by different sensory neuron types with neurons for acute heat, and cold This is with the of other neuron types such as for and reflex behavior to punctate mechanical stimuli and for cold and for heat, and are by several different and chemical are polymodal involved in and chemical In of nerve or inflammatory pain, the is different from that of the Calca+ neurons by pain in by the and cold by and to mechanical stimuli measured by neurons and mechanical inflammatory pain as by or force to as as cold also pain but only when is Nevertheless, the mechanical and cold and neurons mechanical to cold was the measured on is to the neurons the and these studies neurons to be polymodal and to the neuron for as as pain during and However, neurons also and and be summation is for pain in by to of pain with a and pain The of during or can also nociceptive and contribute to or have been found to to and when have been as because are to stimuli, but fire in response to of the are found in such as the and but also in the and can be and of neurons in in Emery and and in in the neurons were found to a to noxious mechanical stimuli, but which when to the inflammatory nerve neurons to and somatic Furthermore, a recent found a of sensory neurons to including and to the of the such as during on is in the same neuron as The that the neurons and is with the of these is from that in sensory neurons to include and and of these are in the when these that of neurons by unique functional and these a that is during pain such as in or The of was and other the was to In to the and and a of the such as and However, is also important the in the and the and the in the Nevertheless, in of of the molecular the and the molecular and in the are to fibers the and neuron types can be into a high-threshold and which about of neurons in the pain is as and pain in a a sharp painful sensation of and when In in to pain is and are to be in the and as by and In the and and were into while the in the led to the of these cell types in the to and and In of and were also as distinct cell types and found to to and in a neuron based on the of and and the of is in neurons and is in In other with polymodal in of and but not In to a of polymodal to or pain has also been in it is these are or is the only neuron a However, is a polymodal not only by but also by and with and of and molecular of it is possible that this neuron is involved in pain and inflammatory pain, likely with the pain elicited by of is to be a mechanoreceptor The and are the of the in and the of and in the same cell the neuron is to be but and In the cold in a much the for neurons based on might also or noxious cold sensation that can be as This is with pain in response to cold in the In the the Calca+ but neurons by to neurons were found to be which as the of the hair and by the pulling of a and of mechanical the to sensory neurons it in Calca+ but neurons and skin as nerve The only neuron and but not in the is the The Npy2r+ neurons conduction were based on a in protective to a sharp while of to punctate stimuli of the same with a activation led to of with conduction in also to pain with an a conduction in in based on the of of in the neuron a contributing to acute noxious cold. Furthermore, a has Calca+ neurons in an of pain which contribute to cold to be shown cold are by mechanoreceptor neurons in the the of touch and are involved in hair and are a of and as around hair neurons in the are the only of In neurons of with and conduction in the Sensory has shown that mechanical to pain on in because such pain is a nerve of in have that during pain in of or during simultaneous of to spinal nociceptive pathways and pain of touch. In have been to contribute to mechanical In a general activation of or innocuous fibers peripheral nerve also neurons and and However, the of for and pain to be of a of somatosensory neurons has led to categorization in and based on molecular This has for the and of of with to neuron types. The that neuron types are tuned to respond to cold, heat, or chemical itch and to convey or or sharp However, a also qualities of sensation, such as for noxious cold, innocuous chemical itch, and mechanical and pain, on the activity of several kinds of sensory neurons and different such as reflexes and pain to the same are elicited by different neuron types. sensory with also functional in the response within the sensory neuron types. the of functions of sensory neurons not to be in and This of sensory neurons has and experiments based on the are to how different sensations are and how molecular within neuron types and functional in the of different sensory neurons contribute to of The have of to