Performance Evaluation and Spatiotemporal Dynamics of Nine Reanalysis and Remote Sensing Evapotranspiration Products in China
Yujie Liu, Wen Wang, Tianqing Zhao, Zhiyuan Huo
Abstract
Evapotranspiration (ET) is a critical component of the hydrological cycle. The eddy covariance data at 40 flux stations in different climatic regions in China were used to evaluate the accuracy of five reanalysis actual ET datasets (ERA5, ERA5-LAND, GLDAS-2.1, MERRA-2, TerraClimate) and four remote sensing estimation ET datasets (ETMonitor, GLEAM4.2a, PML_V2, SiTHv2), which are widely used by the hydrometeorological and climatological communities, in terms of the root mean square error, Pearson correlation coefficient, mean absolute deviation, and Taylor skill score. The results show that remote sensing products outperform reanalysis datasets. Among them, ETMonitor has the highest accuracy, followed by PML_V2 and SiTHv2. TerraClimate and MERRA-2 have the least agreement with the observations at flux sites across nearly all evaluation metrics. All products can capture the seasonality of ET in China, but underestimate ET in northwest China and overestimate ET in southern China throughout the year. We tried to merge three optimal data products (ETMonitor, PML_V2, and SiTHv2) using the triple collocation analysis method to improve the ET estimation, but the results showed that the improvement by the data fusion approach is marginal. The estimation of the multi-year average evapotranspiration during the period from 2001 to 2020 ranges from 397.8 mm/year (GLEAM4.2a) to 504.8 mm/year (ERA5-Land) in China. From 2001 to 2020, annual evapotranspiration in China generally increased, but with varying rates across different products. MERRA-2 showed the largest annual increase rate (3.71 mm/year), while SiTHv2 had the smallest (0.17 mm/year). There are no significant changes in the seasonality of ET by most ET products from 2001 to 2020, except for PML_V2 and SiTHv2, which indicate an increase in seasonality in terms of the evapotranspiration concentration index. This ET intercomparison addresses a key knowledge gap in terrestrial water flux quantification, aiding climate and hydrological research.