Increasing phosphorus plant availability from P-rich ashes and biochars by acidification with sulfuric acid
Clara Kopp, Pietro Sica, Changyong Lu, Dominique J. Tobler, Lars Stoumann Jensen, Dorette Müller‐Stöver
Abstract
Biochars and ashes derived from thermal treatment of P-rich wastes could be used as bio-based fertilizers to improve P recycling. However, thermal treatments often result in low plant P availability. Acidification of these material before soil application could potentially increase plant P availability. Based on the water-extractable P levels obtained in titration experiments, sulfuric acid concentrations between 2.5 M and 10 M were applied to digestate solids char and ash (DS-C, DS-A), poultry litter ash (PL-A), insect frass char (IF-C), sewage sludge char and ash (SS-C, SS-A) and meat and bone char (MB-C). Acidified and untreated materials were applied in a pot experiment with maize in 33P labeled soil to determine fertilizer P uptake. The acidification resulted in a significant increase in P solubility. The amount of acid required depended on the materials’ buffer capacity and P speciation. Based on XRD analysis, we assume that mainly Ca-associated P was solubilized. In the pot experiment, acidified materials outperformed untreated materials and the unfertilized control in terms of biomass and P uptake. The P recovery from the acidified materials ranked in the order DS-C > SS-A > PL-A > IF-C > DS-A > SS-C > MB-C. The acidification did not significantly decrease soil pH, nor was there an effect on plant heavy metal availability. In conclusion, acidification increased plant growth and P uptake without affecting plant heavy metal uptake and soil pH. Therefore, acidification to increase the P fertilizer value of ashes and chars is a promising approach to facilitate P recycling.