Fault detection for district heating substations: Beyond three-sigma approaches

Abstract

The topic of this paper is fault detection for district heating substations, which is an important enabler for the transition towards fourth-generation district heating systems. Classical fault detection approaches are often based on anomaly detection, commonly making the implicit assumption that the errors between the measurements and the predictions made by the baseline model are i.i.d. and following an underlying Gaussian distribution. Our analysis shows that this does not hold up in the field, showing clear seasonality in the error over time. We propose to replace the Gaussian error model by a quantile regression model in order to provide a more nuanced fault threshold, conditioned on time and other input variables. Additionally, we observed that properly training the baseline model comes with its own challenges due to this time dependency, which we propose to resolve by employing an ensemble of models, trained on different periods of time. We demonstrate our method on unlabelled operational data obtained from a Swedish district heating operator to illustrate its use in the field. In addition, we validate it on labelled data from our residential lab setup, testing a variety of common faults. • Fault detection for 4GDH substations commonly assume Gaussian error models • Operational error data shows mismatch between data distribution and Gaussian model • Operational error data is often dependent on time or other features • Quantile regression models offer better represention of these error distributions • Model ensembles of different time periods more robustly determine baseline bahaviour

Topics & Concepts