Blood Gene Expression Profiling and Donor-derived Cell-free DNA to Noninvasively Diagnose Clinical and Subclinical Kidney Transplant Rejection: A Real-life Appraisal Study
Joana Sellarés, Franc Casanova, M. J. Perez-Saez, David Cucchiari, Ana Coloma, A. Vilà, Carme Facundo, Delphine Kervella, María Molina, Francesc Moreso, Edoardo Melilli, Fritz Diekmann, Marta Crespo, Oriol Bestard
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Peripheral blood biomarkers aim to noninvasively diagnose kidney allograft rejection, but most lack robust independent validation. TruGraf is intended to exclude subclinical cellular rejection (TCMR), whereas donor-derived cell-free DNA Viracor-TRAC has proven value in excluding antibody-mediated rejection (AMR). We aim to validate both biomarkers for accurate rejection diagnosis in a real-world clinical setting. METHODS: We prospectively included 230 unselected, consecutive kidney transplants from 6 centers undergoing for-cause and protocol biopsies with paired blood samples from December 2021 to 2022. TruGraf and Viracor-TRAC were blindly run by a central laboratory. RESULTS: The incidence of rejection was 22.6% (17.3% surveillance; 27% for-cause biopsies). Inflammation was associated with higher TRAC levels, with AMR/mixed and microvascular inflammation (MVI) showing the highest levels ( P < 0.05). TruGraf did not associate with any specific allograft injury. No biomarkers, individually or combined, accurately diagnosed any rejection (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve [AUROC] < 0.65). However, high TRAC levels, when combined with DSA in for-cause biopsies, predicted AMR/mixed rejection or MVI (AUROC = 0.817; P < 0.001), outperforming serum creatinine and DSA (AUROC < 0.65). CONCLUSIONS: In this large, prospective, observational real-life study, we were unable to validate TruGraf and TRAC to diagnose rejection but found a useful context of use for TRAC to noninvasively diagnose AMR/mixed or MVI in conjunction with DSA in dysfunctioning graft.