Neutralizing antibody titers six months after Comirnaty vaccination: kinetics and comparison with SARS-CoV-2 immunoassays
Andrea Padoan, Chiara Cosma, Francesco Bonfante, Foscarina Della Rocca, Francesco Barbaro, Claudia Santarossa, Luigi Dall’Olmo, Matteo Pagliari, Alessio Bortolami, Anna Maria Cattelan, Vito Cianci, Daniela Basso, Mario Plebani
Abstract
Abstract Objectives mRNA vaccines, including Comirnaty (BNT162b2 mRNA, BioNTech-Pfizer), elicit high IgG and neutralizing antibody (NAb) responses after the second dose, but the progressive decrease in serum antibodies against SARS-CoV-2 following vaccination have raised questions concerning long-term immunity, decreased antibody levels being associated with breakthrough infections after vaccination, prompting the consideration of booster doses. Methods A total number of 189 Padua University-Hospital healthcare workers (HCW) who had received a second vaccine dose were asked to collect serum samples for determining Ab at 12 (t 12 ) and 28 (t 28 ) days, and 6 months (t 6m ) after their first Comirnaty/BNT162b2 inoculation. Ab titers were measured with plaque reduction neutralization test (PRNT), and three chemiluminescent immunoassays, targeting the receptor binding domain (RBD), the trimeric Spike protein (trimeric-S), and surrogate viral neutralization tests (sVNT). Results The median percentages (interquartile range) for decrease in antibodies values 6 months after the first dose were 86.8% (67.1–92.8%) for S-RBD IgG, 82% (58.6–89.3%) for trimeric-S, 70.4% (34.5–86.4%) for VNT-Nab, 75% (50–87.5%) for PRNT 50 and 75% (50–93.7%) for PRNT 90 . At 6 months, neither PRNT titers nor VNT-Nab and S-RBD IgG bAb levels correlated with age (p=0.078) or gender (p=0.938), while they were correlated with previous infection (p<0.001). Conclusions After 6 months, a method-independent reduction of around 90% in anti-SARS-CoV-2 antibodies was detected, while no significant differences were found between values of males and females aged between 24 and 65 years without compromised health status. Further efforts to improve analytical harmonization and standardization are needed.