Interlaboratory Reproducibility of Standardized Hemagglutination Inhibition Assays
David C. Bibby, Michael Savanovic, Jinrong Zhang, Alessandro Torelli, Rienk E. Jeeninga, Luc Gagnon, Shannon L. Harris
Abstract
Licensure of influenza vaccines relies on the hemagglutination inhibition (HI) assay as the primary method to determine quantitative functional antibody titers. The HI assay is also widely used for influenza virus surveillance, characterization, and epidemiology studies. However, the HI assay has a notable lack of reproducibility and consistency. If serology results are required from multiple concurrent studies supporting the development and regulatory approval of a product, the testing capacity of any given testing laboratory may be exceeded and data from more than one testing laboratory included in regulatory filings. Thus, understanding the reproducibility of HI assay results over time and between testing laboratories is necessary to support a robust clinical trial serology data set. Our results demonstrate that with standardization of key reagents and use of a common protocol by experienced and trained staff, the biologically based HI assay can provide similar results between geographically dispersed laboratories.