Comparison on cooling performance of pre-cooled natural draft dry cooling towers using nozzles spray and wet medium
Jiayu Miao, Suoying He, Yuanwei Lu, Yuting Wu, Xuehong Wu, Guanhong Zhang, Ming Gao, Zhe Geng, Shuzhen Zhang
Abstract
Evaporative pre-cooling technology improves the cooling performance of natural draft dry cooling towers (NDDCTs) by introducing a certain amount of water into the air entrance. This paper compares the effects of different evaporative pre-cooling systems (i.e., normal wet-medium arrangement, A-frame wet-medium arrangement and nozzle spray) on the cooling performance of a 167 m high NDDCT. Based on the meteorological data of Naomao lake in Xinjiang in 2015, two MATLAB programs were developed for case studies. This study finds all the evaporative pre-cooling systems can improve the NDDCT's cooling performance in high temperature period. In non-high temperature period, the NDDCT's performance improvement is unremarkable, and the NDDCT's cooling performance even deteriorates in the case of evaporative pre-cooling using wet medium. In the hottest month of July, the water outlet temperatures of the NDDCT pre-cooled with normal wet-medium arrangement, A-frame wet-medium arrangement and nozzle spray drop 3.2 K, 3.5 K and 3.3 K, respectively when compared with no pre-cooling counterpart. The annual average water consumption values are 39.0 kg/s, 56.4 kg/s and 124.1 kg/s, respectively. Considering all the year around performance improvement, it is suggested to use nozzle spray pre-cooling system while intermittent operation or certain-time period operation should be considered to save water.