Understanding how midwife-led continuity of care can be implemented and under what circumstances: a realist review
Renate Simmelink, Elise M. Neppelenbroek, Anneke Pouwels, Nadine van der Lee, Eva Pajkrt, Kirsten A. Ziesemer, H.W. Harmsen van der Vliet–Torij, Corine Verhoeven, Ank de Jonge, Marianne Nieuwenhuijze
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To understand how and under what circumstances midwife-led continuity of care (MLCC) can be implemented in high-income countries. DESIGN: A realist review was conducted to examine interactions between contexts, mechanisms and outcomes. METHODS: An initial programme theory described a hypothesis of how MLCC might be implemented successfully. Literature from a systematic search on the implementation of MLCC was synthesised and supplemented with unstructured searches to identify literature that reinforced the emerging concepts. The synthesis was an iterative process, endorsed in consultation with stakeholders, leading to a refined programme theory. RESULTS: A total of 45 documents were included. The mechanisms identified can be grouped around macrolevel challenges, leadership, role ambiguity and conflict, and personal and professional boundaries. Despite strong evidence supporting MLCC, diverse stakeholder interests and power dynamics hinder its implementation. Implementing MLCC disrupts established roles and power structures, creating uncertainty and anxiety at all levels. To successfully navigate healthcare providers through the transition, both formal and informal leaders must demonstrate the courage and vision to challenge existing norms. CONCLUSIONS: Realist methodology allowed the identification of mechanisms that often remain unnoticed but significantly impact the implementation of MLCC. Concrete policies and guidelines are essential to ensure consistency in care delivery. Collaborative efforts and a shared philosophy among all stakeholders, combined with strong leadership that builds trust and addresses anxiety, can create a supportive environment for MLCC implementation. PROSPERO REGISTRATION NUMBER: CRD42023446437.