Simpson Grade Revisited – Intraoperative Estimation of the Extent of Resection in Meningiomas Versus Postoperative Somatostatin Receptor Positron Emission Tomography/Computed Tomography and Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Moritz Ueberschaer, Franziska Vettermann, Robert Forbrig, Marcus Unterrainer, Sebastian Siller, Annamaria Biczok, Jun Thorsteinsdottir, Clemens C. Cyran, Peter Bartenstein, Jörg‐Christian Tonn, Nathalie L. Albert, Christian Schichor
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Surgeon's intraoperative estimation of meningioma extent of resection (Simpson Grade, SG) is widely used as a prognostic factor for recurrence. However, the validity of SG is still a matter of debate. In preoperative imaging, 68Ga-DOTATATE/PET-CT has been shown to detect meningioma tissue even more sensitively than magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the Simpson grading within the framework of modern postoperative imaging techniques (MRI; PET-CT). METHODS: At first, patients with WHO grade I meningioma, surgical resection, and postoperative 68Ga-DOTATATE/PET-CT within 6 mo after surgery were retrospectively analyzed. Second, an analogous prospective cohort of patients with WHO grade I meningioma was investigated by comparing SG after meningioma removal with postoperative MRI and 68Ga-DOTATATE/PET-CT within 6 mo after surgery. RESULTS: A total of 37 patients were retrospectively analyzed. In total, 5/8 patients with SG-I and II resections showed tumor remnants according to postoperative PET-CT (SG 62.5% false negative). In the prospective cohort of 52 tumors, PET-CT displayed tracer uptake in 15/37 SG-I or II resections indicating unexpected tumor remnants (SG 40.5% false negative). MRI was false negative in 7 of these 15 cases (MRI 18.9% false negative) (P = .037). Discordant results according to PET-CT were more often found in convexity (40%) and falcine (46.7%) meningiomas than in skull base meningiomas (18.2%). CONCLUSION: Intraoperative Simpson grading is at risk to underestimate tumor remnants, predominantly in grade I and II resections. Postoperative PET-CT improves detection rates compared to MRI. Prognostic impact of postoperative meningioma remnants according to PET-CT needs to be investigated prospectively.