Comparison of Symptoms and Antibody Response Following Administration of Moderna or Pfizer SARS-CoV-2 Vaccines
Michael T. Kelliher, Joshua Levy, Robert D Nerenz, Bradley A Poore, Abigail A. Johnston, Amanda R. Rogers, Mary E. O. Stella, Sarah E. Snow, Mark A Cervinski, Jacqueline A. Hubbard
Abstract
CONTEXT.—: Moderna (mRNA-1272) and Pfizer (BNT162b2) SARS-CoV-2 vaccines demonstrate favorable safety and efficacy profiles, but direct comparison data are lacking. OBJECTIVE.—: To determine the vaccines' side effect profiles and expected antibody responses. These data may help personalize vaccine selection and identify individuals with a suboptimal vaccine response. DESIGN.—: One hundred forty-nine healthy, largely seronegative adults were assigned Moderna (n = 79) or Pfizer (n = 70). Following the second dose, participants completed a survey documenting their side effects. Serum was collected 0 to 4 days prior to dose 2, and 14 ± 4 days, 30 ± 4 days, 90 ± 10 days, and 180 ± 20 days after dose 2. Convalescent serum specimens were collected 32 to 54 days from donors after a polymerase chain reaction-confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection (n = 20). Anti-spike antibodies were measured using the Roche Diagnostics Elecys Anti-SARS-CoV-2 S assay on a Roche cobas e801 instrument. RESULTS.—: Participants receiving the Moderna vaccine experienced side effects with greater frequency and severity. Both vaccines elicited a robust antibody response, but median signal was higher in Moderna recipients. Symptom severity decreased with age. Antibody response in Pfizer recipients negatively correlated with age. Antibody response decreased after 6 months (84% reduction in Moderna, 79% Pfizer), but values remained greater than for convalescent donors. Antibody response did not correlate with gender or symptom severity. CONCLUSIONS.—: Moderna may be preferred in individuals in need of greater immune stimulation (eg, older individuals), whereas Pfizer may be preferred in those concerned about vaccine reactions. Anti-spike antibody signal varies by vaccine, so specific reference intervals will be needed to identify individuals with a suboptimal response.