Secretome Analysis: Reading Cellular Sign Language to Understand Intercellular Communication
Wei Wu, Jeroen Krijgsveld
Abstract
•Cell type-specific and proximity biotin labeling enables secretome characterization.•Glycan-mediated secretome analysis requires carefully controlled interpretation.•Recent trends to perform secretome analysis in vivo.•Computational methods are critical to interpret cellular and organismal secretion. A significant portion of mammalian proteomes is secreted to the extracellular space to fulfill crucial roles in cell-to-cell communication. To best recapitulate the intricate and multi-faceted crosstalk between cells in a live organism, there is an ever-increasing need for methods to study protein secretion in model systems that include multiple cell types. In addition, posttranslational modifications further expand the complexity and versatility of cellular communication. This review aims to summarize recent strategies and model systems that employ cellular coculture, chemical biology tools, protein enrichment, and proteomic methods to characterize the composition and function of cellular secretomes. This is all geared towards gaining better understanding of organismal biology in vivo mediated by secretory signaling. A significant portion of mammalian proteomes is secreted to the extracellular space to fulfill crucial roles in cell-to-cell communication. To best recapitulate the intricate and multi-faceted crosstalk between cells in a live organism, there is an ever-increasing need for methods to study protein secretion in model systems that include multiple cell types. In addition, posttranslational modifications further expand the complexity and versatility of cellular communication. This review aims to summarize recent strategies and model systems that employ cellular coculture, chemical biology tools, protein enrichment, and proteomic methods to characterize the composition and function of cellular secretomes. This is all geared towards gaining better understanding of organismal biology in vivo mediated by secretory signaling. The term secretome was first used in the year of 2000 to designate the secretory processes in the bacteria Bacillus subtilis (1Tjalsma H. Bolhuis A. Jongbloed J.D. Bron S. van Dijl J.M. Signal peptide-dependent protein transport in Bacillus subtilis: a genome-based survey of the secretome.Microbiol. Mol. Biol. Rev. 2000; 64: 515-547Google Scholar) and has since become a generally used term to describe the global group of proteins that are secreted, released, or shed into the extracellular environment by a cell, tissue, organ, or organism at any given time. It has been estimated that the mammalian proteome encompasses nearly 3000 secreted proteins and >2000 that are localized to the plasma membrane, collectively representing some 25% of the proteome (2Uhlen M. Fagerberg L. Hallstrom B.M. Lindskog C. Oksvold P. Mardinoglu A. et al.Proteomics. Tissue-based map of the human proteome.Science. 2015; 3471260419Google Scholar, 3Uhlen M. Karlsson M.J. Hober A. Svensson A.S. Scheffel J. Kotol D. et al.The human secretome.Sci. Signal. 2019; 12eaaz0274Google Scholar). In addition, trafficking these proteins through the secretory pathway is an energetically expensive process, estimated to involve >250 proteins that are needed after the completion of protein synthesis to translocate secretory proteins through the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and Golgi, while assembling disulfide bonds and adding N- and O-linked glycans (4Gutierrez J.M. Feizi A. Li S. Kallehauge T.B. Hefzi H. Grav L.M. et al.Genome-scale reconstructions of the mammalian secretory pathway predict metabolic costs and limitations of protein secretion.Nat. Commun. 2020; 11: 68Google Scholar). This expenditure is warranted by the fact that secretory proteins fulfill a range of important extracellular functions that are key to proper functioning of the cell in its niche, organ, and eventually in the entire organism. Specifically, the secretome comprises a large variety of bioactive molecules such as enzymes, hormones, antibodies, and extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins that provide a scaffolding function in the ECM and that play important roles in regulating cell–cell and cell–ECM interactions (3Uhlen M. Karlsson M.J. Hober A. Svensson A.S. Scheffel J. Kotol D. et al.The human secretome.Sci. Signal. 2019; 12eaaz0274Google Scholar, 5Sainio A. Jarvelainen H. Extracellular matrix-cell interactions: focus on therapeutic applications.Cell Signal. 2020; 66109487Google Scholar, 6Naba A. Ten years of extracellular matrix proteomics: accomplishments, challenges, and future perspectives.Mol. Cell Proteomics. 2023; 22100528Google Scholar). In addition, an important class of proteins is constituted by growth factors and cytokines that signal to recipient cells to induce a specific response. This is not only required to maintain tissue homeostasis in healthy tissue (as further stipulated below) but is also crucial in diseases like cancer where secretory proteins constitute the organizing principle among cancer cells, stroma, and immune cells in the tumor microenvironment (7Propper D.J. Balkwill F.R. Harnessing cytokines and chemokines for cancer therapy.Nat. Rev. Clin. Oncol. 2022; 19: 237-253Google Scholar, 8Padgaonkar M. Shendre S. Chatterjee P. Banerjee S. Cancer secretome: finding out hidden messages in extracellular secretions.Clin. Transl. Oncol. 2023; 25: 1145-1155Google Scholar, 9Robinson J.L. Feizi A. Uhlen M. Nielsen J. A systematic investigation of the malignant functions and diagnostic potential of the cancer secretome.Cell Rep. 2019; 26: 2622-26235.e5Google Scholar). Knowing and understanding the proteins in the extracellular space that sustain the mutual interactions among cells therefore not only provides insight in fundamental aspects of tissue maintenance and onset of disease but may also provide clues for intervention by interfering in this network (7Propper D.J. Balkwill F.R. Harnessing cytokines and chemokines for cancer therapy.Nat. Rev. Clin. Oncol. 2022; 19: 237-253Google Scholar, 10Cox T.R. The matrix in cancer.Nat. Rev. Cancer. 2021; 21: 217-238Google Scholar). Furthermore, it is worth noting that proteins in body fluids like blood plasma and cerebrospinal fluid are all secreted by cells and organs throughout the body, putting secretory proteins at center stage for biomarker discovery. The aim of this review is to provide an overview of proteomic strategies that have emerged recently for the enrichment and characterization of secreted proteins, including their posttranslational modifications. Furthermore, we discuss the application of such strategies towards the recapitulation of systemic cellular crosstalk in vivo. Secretory proteins can either function in an autocrine or paracrine fashion to sustain a host of processes that are essential for tissue homeostasis, development, and response to stress. In autocrine signaling, a cell produces a soluble mediator into the extracellular space that binds to a receptor on the same cell, thereby completing a self-sufficient form of auto-regulation. For instance, autocrine production of transforming growth factor-beta (TGFβ) in cancer is a well-studied yet of In the of is by cell and in the to tumor and J. in Scholar). is mediated by soluble factors by cell and on the to that is on cell and for a and network For instance, is of the paracrine in the human body production of is to immune cells, all cell in the body have to and to or in the Rev. 2022; Scholar). This that immune cells can the tumor microenvironment for of in the important and function of cellular secretion is tissue a large of secreted proteins has functions that and it is that cellular can in C. cell and a Transl. 2021; Scholar). the of cells was to that may of therapeutic cell secretome: therapeutic potential by cellular to the of cellular to in body systems where is yet the of secreted factors have been For instance, cell have been in for or such as or and disease S. Cell secretome: and therapeutic for 2020; Scholar). have also been to of proteins on the of in or A. C. C. J. et al.The secretome of a systematic 2020; Scholar). cell have also been in and S. et of cells in and a systematic Transl. 2020; Scholar). these that cellular may a of potential for in only tissue secreted proteins can also tissue and For instance, autocrine is important in biology and and secreted factors such as and are required for in a of therapeutic 2021; Scholar). of such autocrine can in such as and mediated by secreted proteins are also critical in and tissue are in cancer J.M. in can we Cancer Scholar). The is an important organ, in and are to on roles in and in such cells have been to in paracrine signaling, to production of M. paracrine in the of 2022; Scholar). of crosstalk mediated by are in In for a autocrine was to to large bacteria on to have these and that of autocrine and cells and that these are of a of crosstalk H. and of a Cell Biol. 26: Scholar). proteins are not only crucial in tissue homeostasis, but are also key in This where the tumor microenvironment a of cancer cells, stroma, and immune cells that by and factors to play a in the and of D. of 2022; Scholar, The tumor microenvironment cancer 2019; Scholar). ECM by the of and that ECM in can malignant and tumor and and J. A. of extracellular matrix in and Commun. 2020; 11: Scholar). cells are essential of the tumor where that and immune cells play a in tumor L. Li analysis of immune cells in the tumor Rev. 2021; Scholar). gaining into these interactions mediated by factors the for therapeutic that multiple of the tumor microenvironment the of the of therapeutic for P. J.L. et in cancer J. Cancer. 2019; Scholar, C. tumor microenvironment for cancer J. Mol. 2019; Scholar, J. J. et of the tumor microenvironment in tumor immune Cancer. 2019; Scholar). crosstalk is not proteins in the extracellular space may also as by extracellular protein and in the extracellular This yet of to the of crosstalk mediated by cellular M.J. the protein 2020; Scholar). secretion to the cell can generally to by either or secreted proteins are to the cell by signal J. M. M. functions of the signal in protein the Scholar). are of to at the protein that the towards the secretory The signal of a a and a signal S. M. of on the of the signal in protein secretion the S. A. Scholar, H. J. Li H. H. et in the of the signal to of secretory Biol. at the protein for secretion after plasma the cell The signal of the proteins into the and to the where critical posttranslational modifications including and may are and in the to function and protein in the extracellular environment secretion and the endoplasmic Biol. Scholar). and proteins the network as secretory and proteins the of secretory the plasma membrane, through the of secretory are to the cell J. out molecules the Cell Biol. 2021; Scholar). the of proteins this as as to of secreted proteins not signal and are secreted by that the C. the of Biol. Scholar, of protein Biol. Scholar, C. of protein Cell Biol. Scholar). secretion such as in the of are and as not as L. C. J. J. J. secretion is a of cancer cell Cell Proteomics. Scholar). In addition, of protein secretion have been through receptor a where the extracellular of a protein plasma may by or secreted into the extracellular space of proteins in and recent J. Scholar). A well-studied of this is the and of protein that in the of in disease J. of the protein by human 2019; Scholar). In the secretion of extracellular a of as these may become in and of cancer A. A. M. et 2015; Scholar). are at the of and in the of to or where proteins are into the extracellular space A. P. J. and of protein Cell Biol. 2022; Scholar) It is key to that to the of these can a controlled environment for the proteins and may the of secreted molecules the cells M. L. Li et pathway for protein 2020; Scholar). secretion is not in and also on the cell and and as such in secretion can in response to cellular and In all of secretion it is important to the secretion and the secretion is or cells have a of secretion. The function of such secretion is homeostasis or autocrine the tissue secretion of extracellular protein and can in signal such as secretion at Commun. 2021; Scholar) or in and C. secretion and metabolic of the of the 2020; Scholar, J. of and Mol. 2021; Scholar). secretion human through and but is also a key of the immune to to that an response. The and systems also and for systemic of and The of secreted proteins in aspects of organismal biology has the of a range of methods to the composition of cellular this in vivo of the complexity of systems multiple cell cell in has been a model for secretome analysis either in of specific cell in In addition, a variety of have been to secretory proteins to either by protein modifications as an or by in chemical biology for protein some of these methods are to used to characterize in vivo. describe the methods in the recent their and application to and for the In cell has been a model to the of proteins by specific cell the of cell as a of the cellular environment in vivo. A in the characterization of secretory proteins in cell is the of in For a in can a of to to of protein can of where of the proteins are the blood This in protein the that proteins may by thereby their and by This may by such may a that secretome composition J. J. S. et analysis of secreted proteins in and by and Rep. 2019; Scholar, M. M. S. J. enrichment of proteins for secretome Scholar). of cells is an to cellular This has been for to of in a model for cancer in S. C. et in Rep. 2020; Scholar) or to that the secretome of was a on the of that in coculture, including proteins that secreted by and M. S. C. A proteomic labeling for and protein 2015; Scholar). To potential to of is to cell to by only growth the of S. M. response in model Cell Proteomics. 2022; Scholar). In this the of protein secretion a after of proteins may by In these the in the is to the a of the model protein such that any to the proteins can The in this is that proteins in the model that significant are also for some to have been to for secreted proteins cells in the of enrichment strategies secretome and a these strategies the cellular to into proteins or the J. of proteins in mammalian cells S. A. Scholar). labeling has been to of secreted proteins M. M. S. J. enrichment of proteins for secretome Scholar, J. labeling and for secretome Mol. Biol. Scholar). is that is labeling can the of a first at the and on to to of the protein for by for protein of is that chemical of an protein to is and a that to proteins, such as can to for enrichment of the protein labeling of cells has been to characterize the secretome composition of and this was labeling to in protein secretion M. M. S. J. enrichment of proteins for secretome Scholar). the and of protein labeling can as to proteins that are secreted as a response to the cellular or in a to or processes M. M. S. J. enrichment of proteins for secretome Scholar). This has been used in for to characterize secretome of mammalian cells J. Li A. M. A. et cell 2020; Scholar). In addition, it was to secretory proteins in such as the secretion of was to as a for to J. S. Li A. et analysis of as a in after 2020; Scholar). Furthermore, was to in the microenvironment of and was by function in cell S. M. M. et cellular and is in Oncol. 2021; Scholar). cell labeling has been to secretion of proteins in that on the of a in factors cell and potential autocrine or paracrine roles in tumor onset M. D. S. et in 2022; Scholar). A function of secreted proteins is to between cells in a and The to factors that such of cell to cells in a and perform a secretome analysis J.M. study of and key Rev. Proteomics. 2022; 19: Scholar, S. tumor through Cell Proteomics. Scholar). The of such an is that it only the study of cell that not into the interactions that are to in vivo. the of such can used to and as as by the in To a of cells can in the same M. J. et to through Scholar) or a L. H. L. L. et cells in Scholar) to cellular that requires or is mediated by soluble This has been used to factors secreted by cell has been an to function of the recipient For instance, in the the of cell to the of cancer cell to it was that of is a M. J. et to through Scholar). It was that of the to was in the of and to cells the The that of and can in cancer cells M. J. et to through Scholar) the potential of secretome analysis of systems to factors that may This was in a study that to cancer cells, was by the to that may and L. H. L. L. et cells in Scholar). study used to cellular interactions by of cells, cancer cells, and multiple secreted factors that in et of secreted factors in between or cancer cells and Oncol. 2023; Scholar). these secretion was of cells and cancer cells, and cancer cell the function of the in a it is not to of the cell a protein cell labeling strategies have been that this to cell labeling the fact that is an essential for mammalian In of and in the pathway this by of into et labeling for proteomic of Scholar). The of the in the fact that can that cell in the can only of the and not the that the cell of can the of the secreted proteins as by et labeling for proteomic of Scholar). The was further by and of J.D. L. C. labeling for analysis of in Cell Proteomics. Scholar). a key was the of the enzymes, J.D. L. C. labeling for analysis of in Cell Proteomics. Scholar) that labeling et labeling for proteomic of Scholar). This is an important for secretome since it for of has been used to characterize between cancer cells et of cancer cell and Oncol. 2022; Scholar) or cells S. M. J.D. et tumor cell multiple in either cell In the the was to secreted by cells, been as a in the of these cells as a S. M. J.D. et tumor cell Scholar). these have that can the between cells, in to cellular processes at a that was To this analysis of such is a to the factors that this while this to labeling is to a to into The principle the of a specific to its a of the in principle this can to of and labeling of Rev. of have been for proteomic A. et metabolic labeling of Biol. Scholar). To mammalian cells, best have been by of the of into proteomes of mammalian cell A. J.D. C. M.J. et for analysis of mammalian protein Scholar). The of can used for to for or enrichment of this enables proteomic characterization of cells in cells, where only the This to secretome analysis to proteins in a and in that S. S. S. J. et of the secretome of a specific cell in J. Mol. 2022; Scholar). this a the has been in a model to for proteome of and or of in in S. S. S. J. et of the secretome of a specific cell in J. Mol. 2022; Scholar). It is that this can to cell by of in on an a of in the of in multiple proteins also in including secretory proteins such as and tissue M.J. M. A. et of proteome labeling to cell and Commun. Scholar). This the that cell proteins can and the blood for biomarker for diagnostic The recent that labeling can also in cancer in further this to protein synthesis and secretion in cancer cells in the of their microenvironment in vivo L. S. D. J. et labeling and of the tumor cell proteome of cancer in 2021; Scholar, S. C. D. A. J. et cancer by extracellular proteins in and Commun. 2023; Scholar). This may to cell that have been in the or to the cells are to labeling in cancer cells has the that of cells can in thereby interactions immune cells that may the tumor secretome and ECM composition S. C. D. A. J. et cancer by extracellular proteins in and Commun. 2023; Scholar). In recent has become an to proteins that in a of to its proteome The on the of a biotin to a protein to proteins in its can by for by M. A biotin protein and proteins in mammalian Cell Biol. Scholar, et proximity labeling in cells and Scholar, P. key and to Cell Proteomics. 2020; 19: Scholar). This has been in recent for the characterization of secreted proteins in and in vivo. In but strategies by the biotin in the secretory pathway to proteins on their to the extracellular For instance, et the protein for of secretory proteins through the in cells in cell and in J. H. et and of secretory proteins in the of live Commun. 2021; Scholar). proteins in plasma of these of was the that the used their to proteins in plasma of and proteins that in of been J. H. et and of secretory proteins in the of live Commun. 2021; Scholar). that the same used the signal to biotin to the J. M. S. The secretome provides a to in vivo S. A. 2021; Scholar, A.S. D. D. et of protein trafficking by in vivo Commun. 2021; Scholar, Li et secretome in Biol. 2021; Scholar). et used to it to the and it in to secretory an in the of the protein in plasma of after J. M. S. The secretome provides a to in vivo S. A. 2021; Scholar). this to cell et used of and it in and cells and their secretome composition in cell and in vivo by their enrichment plasma in Li et secretome in Biol. 2021; Scholar). secretome not only to cell but also to the cell of of some plasma these secretome this study in the in vivo the fact that only of in that a of and global of protein by a in the secretion of a a of the is that secretion of was to since it was a that to the of the Li et secretome in Biol. 2021; Scholar). et used an biotin and that it proteins to secreted by and A.S. J. et model for in vivo proximity of the mammalian Biol. 2022; Scholar). it to body in body, in factors including a or function A.S. D. D. et of protein trafficking by in vivo Commun. 2021; Scholar). also this in to the biotin in that of the secretory proteins also in A.S. D. D. et of protein trafficking by in vivo Commun. 2021; Scholar). The of the the and of the and function of secreted proteins in vivo. these versatility in the of biotin the and cell that can and the and disease processes that can A potential in these is the of the of secreted proteins in their tissue can only of a This may not since of these can but on the this may in as as secretome can between the that are the of biotin labeling in to the function of secretory factors in methods to study protein trafficking between 2023; Scholar). This may not need as by the of and in the extracellular fluid and of M.J. S. et of extracellular fluids secreted bioactive proteins and 2023; Scholar). that are secreted through the secretory pathway are protein in the and this can for the and characterization of proteins in the enrichment of and has been H. Li P. et analysis of proteins and Cell Proteomics. of M. of an in vivo and Scholar, H. Li and of labeling and 21: or by A to enrichment strategies for Cell Proteomics. 2021; Scholar, C. labeling and analysis in cells and in Rev. 2021; Scholar). have been to the analysis of and cell proteins, in and in plasma in A. A. A. et of a to proteins in 2019; as for secretome Scholar, S. characterization of extracellular Rev. 2023; Scholar). For instance, enrichment has been labeling to proteome of cancer cell where secretome composition to the cancer stage by the used cell M. of the secretome by cancer and in human blood Cell Proteomics. Scholar). of these proteins also in the potential to proteins in the may have or diagnostic M. of the secretome by cancer and in human blood Cell Proteomics. Scholar). study used and to of human cell secretion of multiple proteins a function in cell and but also in cellular processes J. et analysis of secretome and of human cell shed on Scholar). secretome to of and that are shed into the extracellular space to cellular in For instance, et of in the of cells it as a of this In addition, that of in cellular and thereby in the S. A. D. J. et of cancer by the a secretory protein in cancer 2020; 11: Scholar). the potential of secretome to processes in cancer all of the cellular glycans as a have the of cell cellular or To strategies have been to in for of secretory proteins cell C. labeling and analysis in cells and in Rev. 2021; Scholar). In of or can and into N- and O-linked glycans to a of Scholar). This was used by et in a protein enrichment to proteins by S. A. M. et protein enrichment in J. Scholar). and proteins in the extracellular space on the of a the of protein and a key for In these used to that of signal proteins in N- and in the secretory thereby a in function M. M. S. et analysis signal and a of in multiple Cell Proteomics. 2015; Scholar). of secreted can to their function but also to potential of such that these the same group an of this by including a enrichment of to and J. J. L. M. et the cell J. 2020; Scholar). This to and to the by not in their study S. A. M. et protein enrichment in J. Scholar). In addition, cell secretome of and to proteins that soluble secreted proteins and of shed proteins, of also in cerebrospinal that as diagnostic of disease or of A has been used to secretome after of C. M. M. et secretome analysis of cells enrichment of secreted Scholar). The used for protein the of labeling provides in of and this has not been used in secretome et that labeling can into a for the of cell proteins H. of in this also to secretome labeling has been used to the of secreted proteins by a secretome the S. M. analysis of secreted cells 2021; thereby a as used in of mammalian cells proteome cell Biol. 19: Scholar). labeling and enrichment of proteins, a of the of proteins in the secretome cells that in the of S. M. analysis of secreted cells 2021; Scholar). This was to the was to the in between the and the used for the of the this the to and secretion of proteins, including growth and ECM proteins S. M. analysis of secreted cells 2021; Scholar). labeling has been used in metabolic labeling a of strategies may to expand the of secretome used in to the of of secretory potential of have