Pregnant persons and birth partners' experiences of shared decision-making during pregnancy and childbirth: An umbrella review
Tahani Ali Alruwaili, Kimberley Crawford, Shayesteh Jahanfar, Kerry Hampton, Ensieh Fooladi
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: This umbrella review aimed to summarize evidence on pregnant persons and/or their birth partners' experiences and expectations of SDM during pregnancy and childbirth. METHODS: We searched eight databases from 2011 to 2023. Quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods systematic reviews were included in this review. RESULTS: We have identified 26 reviews that report on 622 primary studies involving over 213,000 pregnant persons and 22,000 birth partners, examining a broad range of decision-making scenarios in maternity care. The three-talk model was used to categorise the themes which include communication, weighing options, and making a decision. Multiple reviews have reported that pregnant persons and birth partners have mixed experiences in several decision-making scenarios, with insufficient information and inadequate consideration or answers to their questions being common issues. Pregnant persons and birth partners prefer clear explanations, simple communication, and involvement in decision-making. Exclusion from the decision-making during pregnancy and childbirth may lead to negative experiences, whilst involvement improves satisfaction, reduces distress and fosters empowerment. CONCLUSIONS: The review highlights the importance of promoting SDM in maternity care, as it is fundamental to promoting maternal, newborn, and family well-being. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Health systems should redesign antenatal classes and train healthcare providers to enhance communication skills and encourage informed decision-making by pregnant persons and birth partners.