Extraction of First Permanent Molars in Children—A Comprehensive Review of History, Aim, Space Closure and Other Consequences
Ahmad Al Masri, Mhd Said Mourad, Christian H. Splieth, Karl-Friedrich Krey, Julian Schmoeckel
Abstract
Compromised first permanent molars (FPMs) in children pose major challenges for dentists and patients even in low-caries-risk populations. Whether due to caries or Molar Incisor Hypomineralization (MIH), compromised FPMs at an early age require careful treatment planning and timing of extraction, if necessary, to eventually have good space closure with healthy dentition. This comprehensive review explains the concept of early extraction of the FPMs in children and lists the results of published studies and systematic reviews regarding spontaneous or orthodontical space closure after the extraction of an FPM, including its consequences in the long term. In general, the majority of the studies confirm that spontaneous space closure after the early extraction of the maxillary FPM could be achieved if the extraction is performed before the eruption of the second permanent molar (SPM). On the other hand, space closure in the mandible is possible in case of optimal timing of extraction and supporting co-factors, but in practice, it would most probably require orthodontic treatment. The decision to retain or extract compromised FPMs must always be made on an individual basis, taking into account all relevant factors and the long-term effects on the entire stomatognathic system. Early prophylaxis to prevent caries and early management of MIH-affected FPMs should, however, be the first-line approach.