A comprehensive uncertainty analysis of model-estimated longitudinal and lateral dispersion coefficients in open channels
Mohammad Najafzadeh, Roohollah Noori, Diako Afroozi, Behzad Ghiasi, Seyed‐Mohammad Hosseini‐Moghari, Ali Mirchi, Ali Torabi Haghighi, Bjørn Kløve
Abstract
The complexity of pollutant-mixing mechanism in open channels generates large uncertainty in estimation of longitudinal and lateral dispersion coefficients (Kx and Ky). Therefore, Kx and Ky estimation in rivers should be accompanied by an uncertainty analysis, a subject mainly ignored in previous studies. We introduce a method based on thorough analysis of different calibration datasets, resampled from a global database of tracer studies, to determine the uncertainty associated with five applicable intelligent models for estimation of Kx and Ky (model tree, evolutionary polynomial regression (EPR), gene-expression programming, multivariate adaptive regression splines (MARS), and support vector machine (SVM)). Our findings suggest that SVM gives least uncertainty in both Kx and Ky estimation, while EPR and MARS generate most uncertainty in Kx and Ky estimation, respectively. By considering significant uncertainty in the model estimations, we suggest that the methodology we introduce here for uncertainty determination of the models be incorporated in empirical studies on estimation of Kx and Ky in rivers.