Wet cooling tower performance prediction in CSP plants: A comparison between artificial neural networks and Poppe’s model
Juan Miguel Serrano Rodríguez, Pedro Navarro, Javier Ruiz Ramírez, Patricia Palenzuela, Manuel Lucas Miralles, Lídia Roca
Abstract
The efficiency of Concentrated Solar Power (CSP) plants strongly depends on steam condensation temperatures. Current cooling systems, either wet (water-cooled) or dry (air-cooled), present trade-offs. Wet cooling towers (WCT) optimize performance but raise concerns due to substantial water usage, especially in water-scarce prone locations of CSP plants. Dry cooling conserves water but sacrifices efficiency, specially during high ambient temperatures, coinciding with peak electricity demand. A potential compromise is a combined cooling system, integrating wet and dry methods, offering lower water consumption, improved efficiency and flexibility. Incorporating such systems into CSP plants is of considerable interest, aiming to optimize operations under diverse conditions. This research focuses on the first step towards this goal; developing static models for WCTs. Two approaches, Poppe and Artificial Neural Networks (ANN), are developed and thoroughly compared in terms of prediction capabilities, experimental and instrumentation requirements, sensitivity analysis, execution time, implementation and scalability. Both approaches have proven to be reliable, with Poppe providing better results, based on MAPE, for the outlet temperature and water consumption (0.87 % and 3.74 %, respectively) compared to a cascade-forward ANN model (1.82 % and 5.21 %, respectively). However, for the target application, the better execution time favors the use of ANNs.