De-implementing wisely: developing the evidence base to reduce low-value care
Jeremy Grimshaw, Andrea M. Patey, Kyle R. Kirkham, Amanda Häll, Shawn Dowling, Nicolas Rodondi, Moriah Ellen, Rudolf B Kool, Simone A. van Dulmen, Eve A. Kerr, Stefanie Linklater, Wendy Levinson, R. Sacha Bhatia
Abstract
Choosing Wisely (CW) campaigns globally have focused attention on the need to reduce low-value care, which can represent up to 30% of the costs of healthcare. Despite early enthusiasm for the CW initiative, few large-scale changes in rates of low-value care have been reported since the launch of these campaigns. Recent commentaries suggest that the focus of the campaign should be on implementation of evidence-based strategies to effectively reduce low-value care. This paper describes the Choosing Wisely De-Implementation Framework (CWDIF), a novel framework that builds on previous work in the field of implementation science and proposes a comprehensive approach to systematically reduce low-value care in both hospital and community settings and advance the science of de-implementation. The CWDIF consists of five phases: Phase 0 , identification of potential areas of low-value healthcare; Phase 1 , identification of local priorities for implementation of CW recommendations; Phase 2 , identification of barriers to implementing CW recommendations and potential interventions to overcome these; Phase 3 , rigorous evaluations of CW implementation programmes; Phase 4 , spread of effective CW implementation programmes. We provide a worked example of applying the CWDIF to develop and evaluate an implementation programme to reduce unnecessary preoperative testing in healthy patients undergoing low-risk surgeries and to further develop the evidence base to reduce low-value care.