Clinically Relevant Genes Identified in Cerebral Palsy Cohorts Following Evaluation of the Clinical Description and Phenotype: A Systematic Review
Yana A. Wilson, Natasha Garrity, Hayley Smithers‐Sheedy, Shona Goldsmith, Tasneem Karim, Georgina Henry, Simon Paget, Maria Kyriagis, Nadia Badawi, Gareth Baynam, Jozef Gécz, Sarah McIntyre
Abstract
A growing number of genes have been identified in individuals with cerebral palsy (CP); however, many of these studies have poor compliance with the cerebral palsy clinical description. This systematic review aimed to assess the quality of the cerebral palsy clinical description/phenotype in cerebral palsy genetic studies published between 2010 and 2024 and report clinically relevant genes based on the quality of the cerebral palsy phenotype. An expert panel developed 6 criteria to review the reported cerebral palsy phenotype/description for each included study. Clinically relevant genes were extracted from each study and stratified into 2 tiers based on the quality. Eighteen studies were included. There was high confidence in the reported cerebral palsy description/phenotype from 8 studies. Of the initial 373 clinically relevant genes, 85 were tier II genes. Individual cerebral palsy motor disorder and phenotype data were absent for 349 of these individuals, limiting further analysis. The tier I gene list was composed of 6 genes: ATL1, COL4A1, GNAO1, KIF1A, SPAST, and TUBA1A. Bilateral spasticity was the most common motor disorder reported in individuals with variants in all 6 genes, and most individuals had accompanying conditions. Prioritizing the accurate reporting of motor and nonmotor phenotypes is crucial for future cerebral palsy genetic studies to further understand the underlying neurobiology.